Photoshop —

Make Layer Duplicates

From the Layers palette menu, select Duplicate Layer to copy the button and its effects. Select Duplicate Layer again to create a total of three layers, each of which shows the same button and styles.

Duplicate Layers

Color the Layers

In the Layers palette, select the Layer 1 Copy layer and double-click the Color Overlay style to open the Layer Style dialog box. Click the color swatch to open the color picker, select a new color, and click OK to accept the color. Click OK again to accept the style change. Go back to the Layers palette and select the Layer 1 Copy 2 layer and repeat this step, selecting a different color.

Layer custom colors